Metal Roof vs Shingles: Which Roofing Option Is Better for Your Home?

Choosing the right roof for your home is a big decision that will affect how your roof will perform in the years to come. 

Your roof protects your home from weather and adds to its overall look. There are many types of roof that are available across the U.S., with the two most popular roofing types being metal roofs and asphalt shingles. 

If you’re confused about whether to choose metal roof or shingles, know that each type has its own strengths and weaknesses. In this article, we’ll compare both to help you decide which is better for your home.

Metal Roof Vs Shingles

How Long Do They Last?

Metal roofs can last for many decades. They hold up well through strong winds, heavy snow, and even hail. They also resist fire, rot, and pests. Once installed, a metal roof can protect your home for a very long time.

Shingle roofs don’t last as long. They may start to wear out sooner, especially in extreme weather conditions. Over time, shingles can crack, curl, or lose the small stones that protect them. You may need to replace a shingle roof sooner than a metal one.

Looks and Styles

Metal roofs come in many styles, including sleek and modern ones. Some styles may also look like clay tiles or wood. You can choose from many colors and finishes. Metal works well with modern and traditional homes.

Shingles also come in different styles. You can choose from three-tab or architectural types. Many colors are available, so it’s easy to match your home’s style. Shingles are common in many neighborhoods and often fit right in.

Energy Savings

Metal naturally reflects sunlight, helping keep your home cooler in summer. Many metal roofs have special coatings that reflect heat even more. This can lower your energy bills if you live in a hot or sunny area.

Shingles generally soak up heat, which can warm up your attic and make your home harder to cool. While some shingles are made to reflect more heat, they still don’t perform as well as metal.

Impact on the Environment

Metal roofs are commonly made from recycled materials. Even when they’ve reached the end of their lifespan, they can be recycled again. This makes them a smart choice if you care about the environment and sustainability. Also, because they last so long, you won’t need to replace them as often.

Shingles are less eco-friendly as compared to metal. Many old shingles go to landfills. Some can be recycled, but the process isn’t as common. Since they wear out faster, you’ll likely need to replace them more than once over the life of your home itself.

Ease of Installation

Given how common shingles are, their installation is more in demand and they’re easy to install. Most roofers know how to work with them. The job goes quickly, and fewer special tools are needed. If a shingle is damaged, it’s easy to replace just that one.

Metal roofs take more skill to install. The panels must line up just right. Flashing and fasteners need to be done with care. Not all roofers are trained to install metal, and repairs can be more complex. However, if you choose a reliable roofing contractor, this won’t be an issue. 

Care and Upkeep

Metal roofs are low-maintenance. You’ll need to check for loose fasteners or debris, but they rarely need repairs. They don’t grow mold or rot, and they resist bugs. This makes them easy to own among metal roofs vs shingles. 

Shingles need more care. Leaves, moss, and mold can build up fast, especially during certain seasons. You’ll need to check for cracks or missing shingles, especially after storms. Regular cleaning and repairs are a must to help keep them in shape.

Weather Performance

Metal roofs are strong in all kinds of weather. They shed snow easily and don’t absorb water. They’re great for fire zones, high winds, and places with heavy snow. Metal also resists heat damage better than shingles.

Shingles do well in normal weather, but they may struggle in extreme conditions. High winds can lift them. Hail and snow can cause damage. In hot weather, shingles may crack or soften over time.

Noise Levels

Rain or hail may sound louder on metal, especially if there’s no insulation. But most modern metal roofs are installed with layers that cut down noise.

Shingles are quieter by nature. Their layers help block out sound. If you want a quiet home during rainstorms, shingles are a good pick.

Insurance and Resale Benefits

Metal roofs may help lower your insurance. Some companies offer discounts for fire-resistant or storm-resistant roofs. A metal roof can also boost resale value, especially in places with harsh weather.

Shingles don’t usually bring insurance discounts. Still, a newer shingle roof can add appeal when selling as it beautifies your home’s appearance. Buyers feel better when the roof looks fresh and solid.

Best Use Based on Location

Metal roofs are great in:

• Places with wildfires
  
  
• Coastal areas with salty air
  
  
• Cold regions with lots of snow
  
  
• Hot areas where heat reflection matters
  

Shingles are a good fit for:

• Mild climates
  
  
• Areas with few extreme weather events
  
  
• Traditional neighborhoods
  
  
• Homeowners wanting fast, simple repairs
  

Your climate and personal needs play a big role in the best choice of roof for you, whether metal roof or shingles.

Which Roof Is the Better Choice?

If you want something that lasts, handles weather well, and needs little care, go with metal. While it does cost more to install, it may save money over time.

If you prefer a familiar and aesthetic look, lower upfront costs, and prefer easier repairs, shingles are a solid option. They work well for most homes and are widely available.

Final Thoughts

Both roofing types protect your home well, but they do so in different ways. Metal roofs offer strength, long life, and energy savings. Shingles give a classic look, easier repairs, and wide use.

When it comes to metal roof vs shingles, think about your weather, your home style, and how long you want the roof to last. A metal roof might cost more at the start but save you time and worry for later (which is not a given!). Shingles are easier to work with and still offer good value.

Choosing the right roof is about more than looks. It’s about comfort, safety, and value over time. Whether you go with metal or shingles, the best roof is one that fits your home and your needs.

Sustainable Living Builders or Slb Inc is a company that supports sustainability through green living solutions, including solar solutions, gutter services, roofing services, and more for both residential and commercial buildings. Offering a free estimate within 48 hours, Slb Inc. offers the best sustainable solutions in all of Sonoma, Marin, and Napa counties in California. 

Related Articles You May Like

✔️ Why a Solar Roof Tesla Is the Perfect Year-End Upgrade
✔️ Roofing
✔️ Roofing Contractor
✔️ Affordable Roofing Services
✔️ Emergency Roofing: What to Do When Disaster Strikes